Well for the first time in over five years of this book club's existence we had a zero turnout for our meeting on Monday. Of course many of us were still digging out from the latest snowstorm but I also heard some negative comments about Sebastian Faulks' Birdsong even though it was voted as one of the most popular books by readers in a BBC poll a few years ago. Maybe we have overdone it on World War 1 novels this year with Itani's Deafening and Pat Barker's Regeneration both of which we discussed a few months ago.
However I very much enjoyed Birdsong and would love to discuss it with someone so catch me at the library or post to this blog with your thoughts.
Next month's book will be a complete change of pace with a whimsical contribution from Alexander McCall Smith The Sunday Philosophy Club. Hope to see some of you then.
Sheelagh Kaplan
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Hi Sheelagh, I apologize for not making the book meeting and so sorry to hear that no one else was there! I am stunned to hear this as I'm sure others will be as well. About the book, I didn't care for the way it began. My usual complaint about how men authors tend to describe love affairs - focusing on the physical to the extreme. I have to amend this opinion to those authors who are also writing about war/military/espionage. "Molokai" was the obvious exception, but it wasn't a war etc. novel. Once "Birdsong" started discussing the war, the author was much more at home. I recently joined the book club & didn't read earlier WWI novels, so this was my first. It led me to the Internet to look up Sommes, Ypres and the monument discussed near the end of the book. I even found a book in our book shelves on WWI by John Keegan that my husband had purchased a while back! I plan to read it. I've found that I can't read these books just before going to bed :-( Very moving... war is horrible, particularly avoidable wars like WWI that led directly to WWII. THank you for all you do; hope to see you 4/5 but still have to get the book if it's available. Mary
ReplyDelete